CHUTZPAH

In 1978, I wrote a paper about the classification of open-channel flow regimes. In this paper, I identified three characteristic celerities and three characteristic diffusivities, from which only four independent dimensionless numbers could be defined. Three of them were well known: the Froude, Reynolds, and Vedernikov numbers. The fourth number was new, and not finding an appropriate reference in the literature, I called it the "Ponce-Simons" number, to include my professor and coauthor Daryl B. Simons.

The Ponce-Simons number characterized unsteady open-channel flow as kinematic (small value), dynamic (intermediate value) or inertial (large value). The idea was based on an earlier paper (1977) entitled "Shallow wave propagation in open-channel flow," which had been well received.

I submitted the manuscript to the ASCE Hydraulics Division Journal, but the paper was rejected. It was returned to me with the following comment from one of the referees: "To range one's name along such illustrious antecessors as Froude, Vedernikov, and Reynolds, is surely the ultimate in chutzpah."

Shortly thereafter, I published a reduced version of the paper 1 in the proceedings of the Fourth Canadian Hydrotechnical Conference. Yet, the experience had taught me a valuable lesson: You can't name something after yourself; recognition is to be bestowed only by others.


1 Ponce, V. M. 1979. "On the classification of open channel flow regimes," Proceedings, Fourth National Hydrotechnical Conference, Vancouver, Canada, May.
 

Emergency spillway at Sheep Creek Barrier Dam, Utah.