CIVE 633 - ENVIRONMENTAL HYDROLOGY

NUTRIENT CYCLES

4.1  PHOSPHOROUS

  • Phosphorous is the most limiting nutrient in fresh water.

  • The annual productivity of fresh waters is controlled more by P than any other nutrient or environmental factor.

  • P can be stored in the sediments, and released slowly later.

  • P reactions at the sediment-water interphase are important to understand the phosphorous cycle and budget.

4.1.1  FORMS OF P

  • P is separated into several forms in the analytical process primarily through mechanical filtration.

  • The orthophosphate anion (PO4-3) is the form available for uptake.

  • The result from the undigested filtrate fraction is referred to as "soluble reactive phosphorous" (SRP) and is analogous to dissolved inorganic phosphorous (DIP).

DIP + DOP = TDP

PIP + POP = TPP

TDP + TPP = TP

SRP --> DIP    (DOP is usually small)

SRP --> TDP

TPP = TP - SRP

  • TP ranges from 5 mg/L (5 ppm) in sewage effluent (most of which is SRP) to as little as 0.005 mg/L (5 ppb) in remote oligotrophic lakes.

  • A detection level of at least 0.002 mg/L (2 ppb) is mandatory in lake research.

4.1.2  GENERAL CYCLE OF P

  • Fig. 4.1 shows the aquatic phosphorous cycle.

  • The ultimate source of P to aquatic ecosystems is from phosphate rock.

  • P is utilized through plant uptake of DIP associated with photosynthesis, chemosynthesis, and decomposition.

  • All organisms require P for metabolism and structure.

  • Photosynthesis is mostly responsible for the uptake of DIP.

  • Macrophytes and bacteria can also remove DIP from the water.

  • Phytoplankton and bacteria are consumed by animal grazers, who in turn are consumed by predators.

  • A fraction of DIP can enter the organic pools (DOP, POP) though excretion and death.

  • DOP and POP can be recycled to DIP by bacteria.

  • PIP and POP can settle into the sediments, and eventually converted to DIP.

  • DIP can be released from the sediments.

  • Sedimentation of dead phytoplankton and fecal pellets from phytoplankton and zooplankton result in loss of P from the open water.

  • Physico-chemical conditions at the sediment-water interphase determine the release of P back to the water column.

4.1.3  SEDIMENT-WATER INTERFACE PROCESSES

  • The exchange of P between sediment and water depends on several factors, acting separately or together:

    • redox potential

    • pH

    • water exchange, as it affects diffusion and transport

    • temperature, as it affects microbial activity

    • relative fractions of P in the sediment that are bound with iron/aluminum, calcium and organic matter.

  • The relative importance of these factors varies with depth and degree of thermal stratification.

  • At the onset of thermal stratification, dissolved oxygen (DO) declines in the hypolimnion due to microbial decomposition of organic matter.

  • As DO approaches 0, reducing conditions prevail and iron in the surficial sediments is reduced from its ferric form (Fe3+) to is ferrous form (Fe2+).

  • P, that was bound to the hydroxy complexes of ferric iron is now solubilized and released into the intersticial pore water, and is available for diffusion into the overlying, anoxic water.

  • The rate of diffusion is a function of the concentration gradient in SRP between the intersticial pore water and the overlying water.

  • The hypolimnetic P content increases more or less linearly throughout the stratified period.

  • Rates of release attributed to the iron redox process are variable.

  • Values as high as 52 mg/m2/day with mean of 16 mg/m2/day have been reported.

  • When the lake destratifies in the autumn, the whole water column and surficial sediments are replenished with DO.

  • Ferrous iron is then oxidized to the ferric state and P is once again sorbed in the hydroxy complexes and returned to the sediments (Fig. 4.2).

  • Under oxic conditions, the solubility of iron is controlled by pH.

  • At pH= 6, the solubility of ferric iron is minimal, and P can be effectively removed from the water column.

  • With increasing pH, the solubility of iron increases and P is released from the sediments.

  • High photosynthetic rates in eutrophic lakes can increase pH to 10, which produces high rates of release of P from the sediments.

  • High pH due to photosynthesis can maintain high P in the water column.

  • Temperature can be important in the release of P from sediments.

  • The role of temperature is related to the stimulation of bacterial activity.

  • Large release of P from sediments during summer can be attributed to iron-redox.

  • In Lake Trummen in Sweden, removal of 1-m of rich sediment quickly resulted in recovery of the lake.

  • Fig. 4.3 shows the redox potential in sediments and overlying water in two English lakes.

  • Fig. 4.10 shows a hypothetical steady-state model of phosphorous cycling in a lake.

  • Conclusions regarding sediment as source or sink of P:

    • Sediments are nearly always a sink for P.

    • Sediments can act as significant sources during a portion of the year.

    • Whether the sediment-released P actually reaches the photic zone and is available for algal uptake is a significant issue.

    • So long as sediments reach the hypolimnion, they are technically a source of P.

    • There is ample evidence to support the statement that some sediment-released P is transported to the epilimnion.

4.2  NITROGEN

  • The nitrogen cycle (Fig. 4.11) is very complex.

  • Two large biological source and sink processes occur with N that do not occur with P.

  • There are:

    • The microbial fixation of N2 from the atmosphere.
    • The return of nitrogen to the atmosphere through denitrification.

  • The processes of nitrification (oxidation of ammonia) and denitrification may occur without biological mediation but at a slow rate.

  • Microorganisms greatly speed up these processes.

  • Nitrogen is most abundant as N2, constituting 78% of the atmospheric gases.

  • Nitrate (NO3-) is the form of nitrogen that can be used by plants.

  • Its concentration varies from a trace when productivity is high, to 1 mg/L when not used.

  • Concentrations above 1 mg/L are usually associated with artificial inputs (fertilization).

  • Ammonia (NH3) or ammonium (NH4+), which is the principal form in water, becomes abundant in the absence of DO or in very enriched waters, but it is usually less abundant than nitrate.

  • Plants often prefer ammonium to nitrate because it is in a more reduced form.
Nitrification
  • Nitrification is the process by which NH3 is transformed first into NO2 and then into NO3.

  • The process occurs only under aerobic conditions.

  • Organisms that normally perform the transformations are Nitrosomonas and Nitrobacter.

  • The yield of energy by nitrification is rather low compared to other transformations in the nitrogen cycle.

2NH4+ + 3O2 --> 2NO2- + 2H2O + 4H+ + energy

2NO2- + O2 --> 2NO3- + energy

Denitrification

  • Denitrification occurs only in the absence, or near absence, of oxygen.

  • A common denitrifier is Thiobacillus denitrificans.

5S2- + 6NO3- + 2H2O --> 5SO42- + 3N2 + 4H+ + energy

  • In denitrification, the bacteria reduce nitrate first to nitrite and then to molecular nitrogen or N2O (nitrous oxide).

  • This process removes nitrogen from ecosystems or wastewater.

  • The necessary alternation of aerobiosis for nitrification, and anaerobiosis for denitrification has implications for management.

  • Example: The Llanos de Mojos "camellones".
Nitrogen fixation

  • Nitrogen fixation is an energy-consuming aerobic process carried on in aquatic environments by bacteria such as Azotobacter and Clostridium and by blue-green algae (Cyanobacteria) Nostoc and others.

  • Nitrogen fixation can represent a significant input of N to an ecosystem.

  • Measured rates are from 0.00004 to 0.072 mg/L/day.

  • In Clear Lake, in California, nitrogen fixation contributed 43% of the annual N input.

  • Because N fixation is an energy-demanding process, it becomes advantageous only when nitrate or ammonium are no longer available.

  • N fixation also increases with productivity as nitrate is depleted.
Implications to nutrient limitation

  • In a freshwater lake, the residence time of N tends to be longer than P, because P tends to be removed to the sediments.

  • N, as nitrate or ammonium, is much more soluble than P.

  • N is limited in enriched waters through denitrification, but not as much in waters of low to moderate enrichment.

  • N fixation from the atmosphere occurs in aerobic environments.

  • N fixation occurs only when ecosystem is depleted of alternate sources of N.

  • N occurs in precipitation more than P.

  • In phosphorous-poor watersheds, little amounts of P in rain can be important.

  • Nitrate in rain is very common, having been transformed from N2 to NO3- in the atmosphere by lighting.

  • There are fewer sources of P than for N, and sedimentation is probably a more efficient remover of P than N in most aquatic ecosystems.

  • In moderately enriched systems, P should be limiting.

  • In highly enriched systems, the recycling of P and the loss of N through denitrification contribute to N being limiting.

4.3  SULPHUR

  • S is almost never a limiting nutrient in aquatic ecosystems.

  • The normal levels as SO42- are more than adequate to meet plant needs.

  • The sulphur cycle is shown in Fig. 4.12.

  • Odorous conditions are readily created when waters are loaded with organic waste to the point that DO is removed.

  • Then SO42- is the electron acceptor used for the breakdown of organic matter.

  • H2S is produced, which has the smell of rotten eggs.

  • If nitrate is available, N-reducing bacteria will dominate and odors will be minimal.

  • Production of SO42- does not persist in the presence of oxygen.

  • SO42- enters aquatic ecosystems through atmospheric deposition of sea salt and as a combustion product of fossil fuels, manifested as acid rain, as well as through natural weathering processes in the watershed.
4.4  CARBON

  • Carbon (C) comprises nearly 50% of the dry organic matter in living organisms.

  • C is usually not limiting to growth.

  • Fig. 4.13 shows the carbon cycle.

  • The atmosphere is a source of C, as with N.

  • Rate of input of CO2 is dependent on the physical process of diffusion across the air-water interface.

  • CO2 currently (2010) comprises 0.04% (400 ppm) of the atmospheric gases.

  • Carbon is present in aquatic ecosystems as CO2, HCO3- and CO32-.

  • CO2 diffuses into water from the atmosphere when the water is undersaturated, and from water to atmosphere when supersaturated.

  • In eutrophic lakes, CO2 is depleted to very low levels causing pH to rise to 10 or more.

  • Photosynthesis and respiration are two major factors that cause a significant departure from equilibrium of the system with the atmosphere.

  • As algae phosynthesize, depleted CO2 can be replaced in water by the following two reactions:

H2CO3 --> CO2 + H2O

HCO3- --> CO2 + OH-

  • If CO2 is replenished from the atmosphere as fast as it is removed by algae, the pH will not change.

  • If algae consume CO2 faster than it can be replaced by diffusion from the atmosphere, H+ will decrease and the pH will rise. Algal uptake usually does exceed atmospheric resupply.

  • The pH will decrease if CO2 production through respiration is in excess of the CO2 loss through diffusion to the atmosphere.

  • Photosynthesis tends to be self-limiting; if CO2 is reduced, the pH rises leading to more reduction of CO2.
 
100927